15% off all orders - LIMITED TIME ONLY! | discount added in cart
LIMITED TIME! 15% off all orders | discount added in cart
Free standard shipping on US orders of $100+

Currency

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Shop these popular collections:

Mystery Damaged Jigsaw Puzzle

Regular price $10.00
Unit price
per

Mystery Damaged Jigsaw Puzzle

Regular price $10.00
Unit price
per
Pieces
Cut Pieces
Difficulty
Availability
Out of stock
(0 in cart)

For a limited time only, purchase a mystery box of jigsaw puzzles that have light damage to the product box. The jigsaw puzzle inside is untouched and in perfect condition. Enjoy savings of up to 75% off - only $10 per puzzle! Your mystery box may or may not include:

  • Puzzles with piece counts ranging from 100-2,000 pieces
  • Brands included are Puzzlefolk, Puzzledly, Piecework, Galison, Fred & Friends, Water & Wines, Jiggy, Cloudberries, eeBoo, Minty Fizz, Talking Tables, University Games, Stellar Factory and more!
  • Puzzle product box that has small dents, creases, and/or tears

We are unable to accommodate special requests due to large demand. 

Product Reviews

Customer Reviews
4.7 Based on 29 Reviews
5 ★
76% 
22
4 ★
14% 
4
3 ★
10% 
3
2 ★
0% 
0
1 ★
0% 
0
Customer Photos
Write a Review Ask a Question

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
L
01/29/2024
Luanne
United States

Mystery treasure

I am now on my third mystery box. My heart always races when I get the notification that the deal is available. I had my poor mum individually gift wrap each puzzle from my last box so I could be even more excited at the discovery. I have gotten a couple of repeats but this has been a great opportunity to try out brands and high quality puzzles I could not otherwise afford

Puzzledly Mystery Damaged Jigsaw Puzzle Review
KP
10/16/2023
Katherine P.
United States

Great puzzles and great deal!

I am so thrilled with my mystery box puzzles. I wasn’t sure what to expect, but I audibly gasped when I opened the box and saw the 2,000 piece gradient puzzle I’d been eyeing for a little while. The puzzles were all in great shape, and the boxes had minimal damage. I would highly recommend if you’re not picky and just looking for a way to add good puzzles to your collection at a good deal.

Puzzledly Mystery Damaged Jigsaw Puzzle Review
A
11/27/2024
Ann
United States

Fun Mystery but only one puzzle

I only read the first few reviews and was excited to receive a box but it only contained one puzzle. The description should be updated stating that there is only one puzzle in the box.

M
10/09/2024
Melinda SVG verified by SHOP
United States

I received one puzzle I already had and one puzzle I didn’t want, but everything else was FANTASTIC. I’m especially excited about trying three new brands. As always, I recommend buying in bundles to increase the chances you get a puzzle you love.

E
09/16/2024
Emily
United States

Mystery box fun

An amazing deal! I've been able to try a variety of brands that I normally wouldn't if I had to pay full price. Highly recommend

LH
07/16/2024
LUANNE H.
United States

5/5 Another thrilling unboxing experience!

As a repeat customer of the Mystery Damaged Puzzle Box, my anticipation never seems to wane with each order, and once again, I was absolutely not disappointed! There's something uniquely exhilarating about placing the order and waiting for your treasure to be delivered. The anticipation of not knowing what I’m about to dive into adds a layer of excitement that’s hard to find in ordinary purchases. I continue to be impressed by the variety and the condition of the puzzles. Unpacking each puzzle brings its own joy and surprises. For anyone who relishes puzzles and the thrill of a good mystery, this is an absolute must-have. Already looking forward to my next box!

R
07/14/2024
Rachel
United States

Blind shopping can be very fun and exciting!

I have never been disappointed in any of the discount damages I’ve ordered. Greatest deal in the puzzleverse.

S
07/04/2024
Shannon
United States

Mystery Fun

I am always shocked by the quality of the puzzles I get from this deal! Most of the time I can hardly tell there is any damage to the boxes. Has been a fun way to try puzzles I normally wouldn't select. Sometimes I have a hard time deciding what to do next and love the randomness of not knowing what is coming!

Buy 3+ puzzles, get 20 % off

discount applied in the cart automatically - cannot be combined with other promo codes.